Types of 510(k) submission

Types of 510(k) Submissions: Traditional, Special & Abbreviated Explained

The FDA recognizes three types of 510(k) submissions: Traditional, Special, and Abbreviated. Each of these is used for a specific purpose according to the device, intended changes, and available evidence.

A 510(k) is a notification showing that a device is substantially equivalent to a previously legally marketed device. The choice of submission type is dependent on various regulatory conditions of the device under FDA’s eligibility criteria.

Choosing the wrong 510(k) type can cost you months of delay. Here’s how to make the right choice based on your device and data.

Understanding Special 510(k) Program

According to the FDA, special 510(k) refers to the optional program for 510(k) clearance when manufacturers make specific device changes to its already approved device. If the manufacturer’s design control procedures consistently provide reliable results, these can help establish substantial equivalence (SE) alongside other 510(k) requirements. 

Note: The special 510(k) program was developed in 1998 as an alternative to the traditional 510(k) pathway.

When do you require the special 510(k)?

A Special 510(k) may be appropriate when:

⦿ The modification is made to the manufacturer’s own legally marketed device.

⦿ The intended use remains unchanged.

⦿ The modification does not alter the device’s fundamental scientific technology.

⦿ Well-established methods are available to evaluate the change.

⦿ The results of verification and validation can be reviewed in a summary or risk-analysis format.

Required documents for special 510(k)

You must have the following documents in hand before applying for the special 510(k) program:

⦿ A cover letter
⦿ The name and 510(k) number of the existing device.
⦿ A detailed description of the device changes prompting the new 510(k) submission.
⦿ A comparison of the modified and cleared devices.
⦿ Any other changes to labeling or design.
⦿ A summary of design control activities.
⦿ Identification of required verification and/or validation activities based on risk analysis. Indications for use form.
⦿ A statement confirming that applicable design and development control requirements under the FDA Quality Management System Regulation (QMSR), 21 CFR Part 820, have been followed, with supporting records available for FDA review upon request.

What is the review timeline for the special 510(k) program?

According to the FDA 510(k) guidelines, special 510(k) submissions are reviewed within 30 days of receipt. However, if the FDA does not approve your modified medical device for a special 510(k), they will automatically convert your submission to a traditional 510(k). The FDA sends an additional Refuse to Accept (RTA) notice after the conversion since a special 510(k) does not comprise all the required information that a traditional program requires. You must keep this in mind when choosing a special 510(k).

Learn more about the FDA’s special 510(k) guidance from their official website.

Understanding Abbreviated 510(k) Program

The FDA also introduced the abbreviated 510(k) program in 1998 as an alternative to the traditional 510(k) program. This FDA clearance program requires you to include all the sections of the traditional 510(k) program.

However, you can provide synopsis reports as a “paper comparison” to demonstrate adherence to abbreviated 510(k) guidance and standards during abbreviated 510(k) submission. In simpler terms, the abbreviated 510(k) program allows you to prove substantial adherence/equivalence of a device via standards. Therefore, you can save time and resources on additional testing or argue using a predicate device to prove substantial adherence/equivalence. 

When do you require the abbreviated 510(k)?

You may require the abbreviated 510(k) program if you have:

⦿ Summary reports comprising the usage of FDA guidance documents for establishing substantial equivalence to an existing device type.
⦿ Synopsis reports proving compliance with device-specific special controls.
⦿ A Declaration of Conformity (DOC) to voluntary consensus standards from 32 organizations like ANSI, IEEE, ISO, and other 29 standard-regulatory organizations. The FDA has a database of recognized consensus standards.

What is the timeline for abbreviated 510(k)?

The FDA requires a 90-day response time for abbreviated 510(k) submissions. However, this may vary in case the FDA refuses the abbreviated 510(k) submission for your device.

You can check the complete timeline here US FDA’s 510(k) Submission & Review Process

How does abbreviated 510(k) differ from traditional 510(k)?

Although these two types of 510(k) programs may seem quite similar, they have some differences that set them apart.

Approval time: Although the term abbreviated may suggest otherwise, both types of 510(k) programs take the same approval time.

Cost: Both types of 510(k) programs have the same costs.

Documentation: These two types of 510(k) programs differ when it comes to documentation. While the traditional program requires detailed documentation, abbreviated 510(k) requires summarized reports on standard compliance with DOC. Therefore, an FDA reviewer may take less time to review abbreviated 510(k) documents and make faster decisions.

Process: Traditional and abbreviated 510(k) submission or approval processes do not differ. Both types of 510(k) programs must follow the same submission and approval formats including the chapter and the structure.

You may learn more about the abbreviated 510(k) program from the FDA’s official website.

Understanding Traditional 510(k) Program

The traditional 510(k) is the most common among the types of 510(k) programs. It refers to the program that manufacturers must follow to provide substantial equivalence for their newly manufactured medical devices. Around 79% of manufacturers make traditional 510(k) submissions before marketing their new devices.

When is Traditional 510(k) Required?

Traditional 510(k) can be required when you want to market a newly manufactured device without 510(k) clearance and that does not need the PMA process. You may also require it to approve changes to cleared devices that don’t qualify for a special 510(k).

Documents Required for Traditional 510(k)

For traditional 510(k) you require must have the following documents:

⦿ A cover letter.
⦿ An index comprising contents with page numbers for each section.
⦿ 510(k) acceptance checklist for the chosen type of 510(k) program selected.
⦿ A guide for the right usage of the device and who should use it.
⦿ A synopsis report of your substantial equivalence argument.
⦿ Submission certificate stating your submission’s accuracy and truth.
⦿ Your device’s proposed labeling.
⦿ Comprehensive device specifications with descriptions, diagrams, engineering drawings, and illustrations.
⦿ Differentiation between your device and the predicate one for substantial equivalence establishment.
⦿ Performance data from clinical to nonclinical test results.
⦿ Add any other required items for your device type.

What can be the outcomes of a Traditional 510(k) Submission?

The FDA can provide the following two determinations for your traditional 510(k) submission:

⦿ Substantial Equivalence (SE): SE means your device is approved for distribution in the US market.
⦿ Not Substantially Equivalent (NSE): In the case where the FDA finds the device to be not substantially equivalent to the intended predicate device, then the marketing process through the 510(k) application cannot proceed. Depending on why the device was found not to be substantially equivalent, the manufacturer can pursue a different route including pursuing a new 510(k), among others.

Traditional 510(k) Submission Review Process

Among other types of 510k submissions, the FDA responds to traditional 510(k) requests within 90 days of receiving the receipt. However, the FDA may pause the review process due to the requirement for additional information.

The step-by-step overview of the traditional 510(k) submission review process looks like this:

⦿ Within 7 days, you may receive an acknowledgment notice for your submission receipt. This notice will include a unique 6-digit K number and the submission date from the FDA.

⦿ Within another 15 days, the FDA will send you the results of their initial acceptance review, that is, accepted or RTA. The initial acceptance review checks if you have submitted all the necessary elements and documents for a substantive review of your device. 

The FDA may provide an RTA notice if they find any problem related to your 510(k) submission. You have to address these problems within 180 days to resume the review process.

⦿ Once the FDA accepts your submission, they move on with the substantive review phase. The FDA will contact you within another 60 days for the next step of the process, that is, a substantive interaction. 

This interaction process has two methods. First, they will contact you via email or phone call for an interactive interview. In this interview, they will request you to provide answers to any questions they might have. Second, they may request additional information (AI).

In case you receive an AI request, you will have to provide them with all the necessary information within 180 days to resume the review process.

⦿ Within 90 days, the FDA will provide the declaration of a SE or NSE for your manufactured medical device.

Conclusion

Navigating the FDA’s 510(k) premarket notification can be challenging, especially with three types of 510(k) programs to choose from. Each program has its unique requirements and timelines.

This article has covered as much as possible about these types of 510(k) programs. To make the right choice, we recommend consulting with a regulatory and quality compliance expert who can provide valuable guidance on selecting the right program and streamlining the submission process. They can help understand the differences, ensure compliance, and optimize chances for timely approval.

With the right support, you can efficiently bring your medical devices to market while meeting FDA standards.

How can Elexes help you with different types of 510(k)?

Elexes Medical Consulting is one of the popular and trusted names in the regulatory and quality compliance industry. With over 50+ years of experience, our team of professionals has helped 200+ clients worldwide to streamline 501(k) submission and approval processes with their expertise and unbiased assistance. We have assisted major companies in the biologics, food, medical device, and pharmaceutical industries to get timely approvals for their breakthrough innovations. Contact us today and get your device on the market on time!

Not sure which FDA 510(k) submission type is appropriate for your device? Elexes can help assess your device's regulatory requirements, submission eligibility, and supporting documentation.

FAQs

  • Which 510(k) type has the shortest review time?

    The Special 510(k) typically has the shortest review time, with an FDA goal of 30 days, provided all eligibility criteria are met.

  • Can I change my 510(k) type mid-process?

    In general, no. You must withdraw and re-submit under a different type if the content no longer supports the original submission type. Besides, the FDA may convert a Special or Abbreviated 510(k) to a Traditional 510(K) during review if it does not meet eligibility requirements.

  • Is Special 510(k) faster than Traditional?

    Special 510(k) submissions have an FDA review goal of 30 days, compared with the 90-day review goal for Traditional 510(k) submissions. However, eligibility depends on the nature of the modification and whether verification and validation results can be evaluated in a summary or risk-analysis format. Performance testing may still be required.

  • What if my device is novel or lacks guidance?

    If no predicate or guidance exists, the De Novo pathway may be more appropriate than a 510(k) submission.

  • Can I use consensus standards for an Abbreviated 510(k)?

    Yes. Abbreviated 510(k)s rely on recognized consensus standards and guidance documents to streamline the review process. A Declaration of Conformity(DOC) to these standards must be included as part of the submission.

Share This: